Friday, November 20, 2026

Fandom Friday: Random Fandom Thoughts #57: Buck and Eddie and Athena Grant (9-1-1)


Happy Friday! I'm posting this early because these two fandom thoughts have been on my mind since last night.

- Last night's 9-1-1 episode Et Tu? (season 10 episode 6) really proves that the Showrunner and writers really will put Evan "Buck" Buckley with anyone but Edmundo "Eddie" Diaz. Since the sixth season, Buck has dated Natalia, a death obsessed Death Doula (season 6), dated Tommy Kinard, a rude and dismissive firefighter (seasons 7 and 8) and not to mention he was shown being racist and sexist in various season 2 episodes. Buck also hooked up with Jade and Zane Williams, a weird married couple (season 9 episode 7) and hooked up (off screen) with Dixie Bennings, an older woman who is also the mother of one of the Nashville firefighters (9-1-1 Nashville season 1 episode 12).

And now in last night's episode Et Tu?, he hooked up with Nadia, a woman who has issues with drugs. It's bad enough Buck met her at their addiction anonymous meeting but then they went to dinner and later hooked up. And then for some reason, Buck felt like he had an instant connection with her. So someone who has an addiction and also nearly died from an overdose but didn't thanks to Buck (who probably went over to her house hoping for a second hook up) found her. And not to mention she also has child custody problems and this is the person they wanted to put Buck with instead of his best friend Eddie. I don't know why the writers keep having Buck have these insta-love connections with his hook ups and then try to turn them into relations which end up blowing up in his face when they don't work out. I guess this is the endless cycle they keep Buck on instead of putting him in a relationship with Eddie who he has an actual connection and chemistry with. And with that said, I wonder who Buck is going to either date or hook up with next: a killer who dresses up as a clown, a bank robber, an arsonist, an evil business owner, a kidnapper, a true crime podcaster who is killing people for stories, I mean the list of potential horrible people is rather endless.

It's so disappointing that Buck and Eddie will never get their happy ending together because the Showrunner and writers are not just set on putting Buck with anyone but Eddie. But do the same for Eddie as well. And since it's a pattern that once either Buck or Eddie gets a random love interest or hook up with one, the other tends to get one next. Eddie tends to be a relationship kind of guy so there probably won't be any hook up for him. But I'm sure when the show returns from hiatus, they will probably introduce some new love interest for Eddie. Since the sixth season, Eddie has met and dated Marisol, a DIYer who had an incestual vibe with her brother and was also a former nun (seasons 6 and 7) and met Kim, a woman who was a look-a-like/doppelganger of his late wife Shannon (season 7 episodes 7 and 9). With Kim, he wasn't interested in her romantically, he was just drawn to her because she looked like Shannon.

Last season they tried introducing a new love interest Alex, who was boring and really bad at her job as a LAPD therapist in the episode War (season 9 episode 8) which was right after the episode Buck hooked up with the married couple. However for Eddie they ended up cutting that romantic storyline with Alex. I wouldn't be surprised if it was due to Eddie and Alex having no chemistry. So, I wonder who they will bring in for Eddie next, they always give him the most bland and lackluster love interests. He really should have had his long over due coming out story because why are they still trying to pair him with women and those relationship go nowhere. His relationship with Dr. Ana Flores back in seasons 4 and 5 very much proved that. I don't know how many times they have to keep trying to prove this point before they finally let him out of the closet.

As for last night's episode, that Eddie and Buck apology scene near the end was nice but after all the arguing and Buck being unnecessarily mean and angry at Eddie it felt like there should have been more to Buck's apology. But I'm glad he at least apologized but that scene really could have become the start of something more developing between them. However, the writers continue to avoid it. I can't help thinking of how The Rookie Showrunner and writers at first avoided putting Lucy Chen and Timothy "Tim" Bradford together despite how popular they were with fans. Especially since that wasn't something the show was planning to do. But they eventually did and since then Lucy and Tim have been one of the show's most popular and fan favorite couples. However, 9-1-1's Showrunner and writers continue to avoid putting Buck and Eddie together and most likely never will. Anyway before this becomes any longer, I just wish one of those entertainment journalists would ask the showrunner why are you so set on not putting them together?

(9-1-1 season 10 episode 6: Et Tu?)


- Something else about last night's episode of 9-1-1, I want to talk about is I believe Athena Grant was poisoned. And I have two theories, first was that paper towel that Agent Lettie Kennedy gave to her. Because Athena not only wiped her hands with it but patted her face with it. So there could have been some kind of poison placed on it that was absorbed through her skin. And second was the poison could have been in that pitcher of water she poured into a glass after she went into the interrogation room. She did take several sips of water before she started feeling sick before she passed out. I guess I'll have to wait until the show returns in January to see if either of my theories are right.

(9-1-1 season 10 episode 6: Et Tu?)

No comments: